Why Pakistan’s Establishment Views a Re-elected Modi as a Challenge

In Shorts:

• Pakistani analysts point to PM Modi’s firm stance on Kashmir and national security as a primary reason for strained relations, moving away from softer diplomatic approaches of the past.
• India’s growing global stature and deepening strategic alliances, particularly with the West and Middle East, are seen as diminishing Pakistan’s traditional role and leverage.
• The rise of a more assertive, culturally confident India under Modi is perceived as an ideological threat to Pakistan’s own national identity and narrative.

---

Why Pakistan’s Establishment Views a Re-elected Modi as a Formidable Challenge

NEW DELHI – The resounding victory of Prime Minister Narendra Modi for a historic third term is being closely watched in capitals around the world. But perhaps nowhere is the analysis more pointed and apprehensive than in Pakistan, where policymakers and security experts view his continued tenure through a lens of strategic unease.

For observers on the other side of the border, Modi’s India represents not just a political rival, but a fundamental shift in the subcontinent’s power dynamics—a shift that they perceive as largely unfavorable to Islamabad’s interests.

A Doctrine of Strategic Assertiveness

Gone are the days of tentative diplomacy, from Pakistan’s perspective. The Modi administration, since first coming to power in 2014, has championed a foreign policy doctrine marked by overt assertiveness, particularly on issues core to national security. The most glaring example, cited unanimously by Pakistani analysts, is the monumental decision of August 2019: the abrogation of Article 370 and the bifurcation of Jammu and Kashmir into two Union Territories.

This move, which India hails as an internal matter crucial for integration and development, is seen in Rawalpindi and Islamabad as an uncompromising hardening of position. It effectively removed a key, longstanding item from the realm of bilateral negotiation, demonstrating a willingness to act unilaterally on what was previously a central dispute.

The Erosion of Pakistan’s Diplomatic Leverage

Beyond direct actions, Pakistan is deeply concerned by India’s successful repositioning on the global stage. Under Modi, India has cultivated stronger ties with the United States while remaining a critical partner for Russia. More notably, its influence in the Middle East, traditionally a region of strong Pakistani affiliation, has grown significantly.

This diplomatic ascendancy is perceived as a direct threat. As India becomes an indispensable strategic partner for major powers and a key economic player, Pakistan fears its own ability to internationalize the Kashmir issue or rally support against India is diminishing rapidly. The world, from this viewpoint, is increasingly inclined to see issues through New Delhi’s strategic lens.

The Ideological and Domestic Front

The challenge is not perceived as merely political or military; it is also ideological. The vision of a “New India” under Modi—confident, muscular, and rooted in its cultural identity—presents a narrative counter to Pakistan’s foundational two-nation theory.

This assertiveness resonates domestically within India, creating a powerful national consensus on security matters that, in turn, limits the scope for any government to pursue softer policies toward Pakistan without being seen as weak. For the Pakistani establishment, this domestic consolidation in India translates into a predictable and unyielding adversary across the border, regardless of which party is in power.

A Prospect of Continued Stalemate

The collective assessment among Pakistani security and policy circles is that a Modi-led India is unlikely to revert to the more fluid diplomacy of earlier eras. The expectation is for a continuation of a hardline posture, where meaningful dialogue is preconditioned on an absolute cessation of cross-border terrorism and a silent acceptance of the new status quo in Kashmir.

For Pakistan, this translates into a protracted period of difficult bilateral relations. The Modi premiership, from their vantage point, symbolizes a definitive end to the old playbook of India-Pakistan relations, forcing a recalculation of strategy in a new and more challenging geopolitical reality.